Oil Painting Color Vibrancy: Why Did the Old Masters Use the Grisaille Painting Technique?

I recently received a great question from an online subscriber about Grisaille painting and its impact on color vibrancy.

Specifically, the question was about how painting a black and white painting underneath the colors applied over them affects the beauty of the color– and it's a great question, it’s an important consideration for any artist exploring this technique.

Grisaille paintings use shades of gray to establish values and composition before applying color. This method was popular in early Italian Renaissance art, where artists like Raphael used black and white as a preliminary study, similar to charcoal sketching but with paint. By focusing on light and shadow, they created realistic folds and forms, bringing depth and dimension to their works.

Prioritizing Value and Contrast over Vibrant Color

It’s important to remember that traditional Grisaille paintings prioritize value and contrast over vibrant color. This doesn't mean the final painting lacks color; it simply means the emphasis is on shape and value relationships. Think of artists like Raphael – his paintings are renowned for their beautiful color schemes, but they were built upon a strong foundation of tonal values established through grisaille techniques.

Now, let’s talk about the trade-off: using gray underneath inherently lowers the intensity of colors applied over them. All Pigments have oil in them; therefore, they have a degree of transparency... to all colors! ... even the opaque ones! when semitransparent and transparent colors are played over the underneath grey pigment the result is less vibrancy compared to painting directly on a white canvas.

Mood and Aesthetics

However, this doesn't make Grisaille paintings inferior. On the contrary, it creates a different mood and aesthetic depending on the artist's intention. By using Grisaille, artists deliberately choose to emphasize contrast over pure color brilliance, often achieving a more somber or dramatic effect, not less just different.

Personally, I often use Grisaille as a preliminary study to refine my values and compositions before applying full color on a separate painting. It allows me to experiment with light and shadow without worrying about the exact hue of each area. This helps ensure that when I add color, it sits beautifully within the established tonal structure.

And hey, if you want to learn more - check us out. At Art Secrets Studio, we believe that everyone has the potential to be an artist. We'll teach you some of these tools and knowledge you need to unlock your artistic potential. In the process, we'll demystify the theories and concepts of the Old [guys] Masters and help you understand how to apply them in your art. Our systematic modules teach you to the tools for application.

More information can be found at our website: www.artsecretsstudio.com